Halloween in Columbus with the Mill Race Monster

Everyone loves a good ghost story, and 50 years ago, Columbus, Indiana, got its very own urban legend: the Mill Race Monster (cue the spooky music).

An urban legend is typically defined as a modern myth or tale, a genre of folklore passed down through generations. But is the Mill Race Monster really just a legend?

Take a Trip back in time

1974

Nov. 1: Women report sightings; creature allegedly jumps on car.

Nov. 5: Men see figure near covered bridge; UFOs also reported.

Nov. 8: Dogcatcher Rick Duckworth spots tall, green-blanketed figure.

Nov. 12: The Republic editorial urges calm.

Mid-Nov: Park closed at night; monster hunters still searching.

Nov. 20: “Monster Roast” on city agenda; sightings fade.

Nov 1, 1974

3:00 pm

The Columbus Police Department received a call from several women who claimed they saw “a monster” while driving through Mill Race Park around 3:00 p.m. They described the creature as standing 6 feet tall, walking upright on two legs, and covered in dark fur with a pale green face. Despite an immediate search of the area, the police found nothing to support their claims.

11:45 pm

Later that night, around 11:45 p.m., another group of women rushed into the Columbus Police Department, terrified. They reported that a hairy creature with a green face had leaped onto their car hood, attempting to break through the windshield with its long, sharp claws. When the police suggested it might be a prank, the witnesses insisted, “This did not look like a mask.”

Deep scratches on the car’s hood seemed to support their story, but a second search of the park yielded no trace of the creature.

Credit: Photo Courtesy of Paraholics

The following Month

Over the course of the month, there were four reported sightings and strange footprints found in the area, leading to one of the largest monster hunts in U.S. history. The city even closed the park for public safety. Theories about the creature’s identity have ranged from a man in a costume to Bigfoot, an alien, or even a military experiment.

However, to this day, one eyewitness has stuck to her story. In an interview with local TV station FOX8, Tyra Cataline recounted, “We thought we were going to die. All three of us thought we were going to die. It was something. I don’t know what it was, but it wasn’t somebody wearing a costume.”

See Full Interview

Credit: Photo Courtesy of Paraholics

Wait there's more?

But the Mill Race Monster isn’t the only scary tale within the streets of Columbus. The town has several locations rumored to be haunted. The historic Crump Theatre, once a vaudeville and opera house, is said to be one of the most haunted places in Columbus. The most famous ghost is “The Lady in Black,” who has been seen on the staircase in a period-style dress. Other claims include sightings of ghostly children and men, reports of people being touched, and hearing disembodied voices. Music has even been heard coming from the top of the staircase.

The Crump Theatre has welcomed numerous paranormal investigations over the years, and to celebrate its 135th anniversary, it will hold a paranormal conference to investigate the building. Other notable haunted spots include the Bartholomew County Historical Society, where doors have been seen opening on their own, and Viewpoint Books, where books have reportedly flown off the shelves in the basement and footsteps have been heard after hours.

Visit Columbus, IN, and delve into the paranormal activities around town. You never know—you just might catch a glimpse of something unexpected and unforgettable.

When Darkness Falls at Ceraland

Every Friday and Saturday in October, 8:00 pm-11:00 pm, $15 per ticket. Do you have what it takes to make it through the woods?

Sammy’s Ghost House at Ceraland

Every Friday and Saturday at 6:00 pm – 9:00 pm, $5 per ticket Have a younger ghost or ghoul coming along? Try out Sammy’s Ghost House for children.

Halloween Fun at Ceraland

Every Friday and Saturday Join in hayrides, ghouly golf and a movies at the campground!

Whipkers Market

Saturday, Oct 12 & 19 Enjoy a FREE Corn maze, You-Pick Pumpkin Patch, Food Truck, & Farmer Alan Pumpkin for kids 10 & under. Corn Maze & Pumpkin Patch open Saturday – Monday.

Bush’s Market

Sat, October 12, 10-5 Sun, October 13, 12-4 The Pumpkinator is back! Come on out and see the pumpkin cannon in action!

The Haunting

Open Friday and Saturday in October Non-scare & kid friendly 4pm-6pm Scare time 8pm 11pm Down the path of twisted mazes and pipes are the many zombies, ghosts, and ghouls that are…

Haunted Museum

October 27th from 5:00 pm – 7:00 pm Enter through the secret door and try to escape the Other World. The night will include button eyes, jumping mice, mango smoothies & slugs…

Park of the Living Dead

October 25, from 7:00 – 8:00 Mill Race Park will be overrun with zombies. As survivors, it is your job to secure shelter, find food, train with a weapon, gain access to…