Thrifting, Picking, and Antiquing in Columbus, Indiana

Today antiquing or thrifting is seen as a sustainable way to source new home décor and clothing items and the best way to find unique and vintage items.

Any true “thrifter” will tell you, you never know what you will find and what new discovery you will need to take home with you! Shop at these local spots and discover something unexpected! Don’t forget to share your favorite moments with us using #visitcolumbusin and tag us @visitcolumbusin to be feautred in our newsletter or social media pages.

Exit 76 Antique Mall

12595 N Executive Drive, Edinburgh, IN 46124

Located just seven miles north of Columbus, Indiana, and just off I-65, the Exit 76 Antique Mall is the largest antique outlet mall within hundreds of miles. You just do not know what will catch your eye, spark a memory, or warm your heart while you are discovering something interesting around every corner.

For those hard-to-find items, unusual collectibles, or unique gifts, the Exit 76 Antique Mall is the ideal place to shop and browse, where the antiques and collectibles change daily.

It is climate-controlled, 72,000-square-feet, and all on one level. You will find over 360 merchants from across the United States, 600 booths, a customer lounge with vending and large-screen TV, and easy access to many restaurants nearby. There are over FIVE MILLION items under one roof!

Explore Exit 76 Attractions

Days of Old Antique Shoppe

3850 25th St, Columbus, IN 47203

Explore over 10,000 square feet of retail space! This expansive layout allows for an impressive and diverse selection of items, catering to a wide range of tastes and interests. This welcoming and thoughtfully curated environment invites customers to browse leisurely, making it an ideal destination for those seeking to uncover hidden treasures while enjoying a delightful shopping experience. Browse the shop and explore the diverse selection of items, including furniture, glassware, jewelry, art, and other unique finds that cater to a range of tastes and interests.

Credit: Photo courtesy of Days of Old Antique Shoppe

Out of the Blue Finds

1600 Central Ave, Columbus, IN 47201

The store is known for offering a diverse range of unique items, from vintage furniture and home decor to quirky collectibles and “out of the blue finds.” It is a popular vintage shop for those who enjoy treasure hunting or are looking to add some character and history to their home. It has a mix of mid-century modern, rustic, and industrial styles.

Credit: Photo courtesy of Out of the Blue Finds

Pickers Paradise

1750 25th St, Columbus, IN 47201

Well, the name says it all!

If you are looking for a wide variety of styles, this is the place for you! From antiques to farmhouse chic, there is a little bit of everything. Given Columbus’s appreciation for design, you might also come across unique or vintage items reflecting the city’s aesthetic influence.

Credit: Photo courtesy of Pickers Paradise

Reroute Resale

1117 16th St, Columbus, IN 47201

For those who love style and savings, Reroute Resale is a must-visit. This high-end curated consignment boutique offers a carefully selected mix of designer brands like Lululemon, Jimmy Choo, and more. It’s the perfect spot to score luxury fashion at a fraction of the original price—proof that you don’t have to spend big to look chic.

Willow Leaves of Hope

326 Jackson St, Hope, IN 47246

Located on the charming town square in Hope, Indiana, this family-owned destination offers a little bit of everything. Enjoy a cozy dining experience at the restaurant, browse through unique furniture, trendy fashions, and home decor finds. It’s not just a shopping spot—it’s also a hub for entertainment with a dinner theater and event center, making it a perfect place to spend the day exploring. Whether you’re looking for a great meal, unique antiques, or a fun night out, this spot has something for everyone.

Credit: Photo courtesy of Willow Leaves of Hope

Gold Nugget Pawn Shop

344 Jackson St, Hope, IN 47246

Don’t let the name fool you—Gold Nugget Pawn Shop is more than just a typical pawn shop. It’s a place with a wide range of items, including guns, instruments, and jewelry. They’ll purchase individual pieces or entire collections, whether they’re modern or antique. It’s a unique stop that combines the thrill of finding hidden treasures with practical services.

Credit: Photo courtesy of Steven Willmy

Vic's Antiques & Uniques

11490 N US 31 Edinburgh, IN 46124

Vic’s Antiques & Uniques in Edinburgh, Indiana, offers a treasure trove of unique finds. This shop is known for its eclectic collection, which feels like a walk through a museum where everything is for sale. You’ll find a mix of antiques, collectibles, and unexpected oddities, from vintage items to mid-century modern pieces. The friendly atmosphere and ever-changing inventory make it a favorite spot for antique enthusiasts and casual shoppers alike

Credit: Photo courtesy of Vic’s Antiques & Uniques

Nichols & Dimes Antiques

101 Pennsylvania St, Elizabethtown, IN 47232

Established in 1981, and nestled in Elizabethtown, Indiana, a charming farming community just six miles southeast of Columbus, Nichols and Dimes offers a delightful escape into the world of antiques. Situated on a scenic four-acre farm, the property includes a home built in 1870, once part of a sprawling 2,200-acre estate.

Guests to Nichols and Dimes are greeted by friendly farm residents, like Sadie the horse, and an assortment of curious cats that always capture the attention of young visitors.

Nichols and Dimes has become a cherished destination for antique lovers. The shop features an eclectic selection of antique furniture, quilts, coverlets, toys, kitchen utensils, pottery, dishes, Christmas collectibles, and books. It’s a place where nostalgia meets discovery, offering a little something for everyone.

Credit: Photo courtesy of Nichols and Dimes Antiques

Mine Yours and Theirs

2310 N National Road, Columbus, IN 47201

Where the past and present collide in everyday finds. From vintage jewelry and timeless antiques to practical tools, this treasure trove delivers variety and nostalgia. Listed under thrift shops, antique stores, and jewelry retailers, it draws longtime thrifters and casual browsers alike. Plus, as a licensed FFL dealer, it’s equipped to handle firearm transactions with professionalism and care.

Redefined

1609 Cottage Ave, Columbus, IN 47201

Redefined offers a beautifully curated selection of luxury women’s consigned fashion at accessible prices. You never know what you will find! Whether you’re looking for timeless vintage pieces, high-end designer finds, or stylish everyday wear, Redefined blends sophistication and sustainability in a charming, boutique setting.

Grizzleepretty Thrift Shop

2521 25th St, Columbus, IN 47201

If you’re looking for a place packed with nostalgia, check out Grizzleepretty Thrift Shop. This local gem is full of vintage toys, household items, tools, books, and DVDs—perfect for anyone who loves uncovering treasures from the past. With new items added daily, there’s always something exciting to discover. Be sure to stop by and see what hidden gems you might find!